We’ve all been there. We buy a planner (or three) in a rush of January hope. We love the cover, the pages, the possibilities! We write our goals in our best handwriting, without a single mistake, and spend hours setting it all up. We love it! And now it sits under a stack of papers, just looking at us. (Ask me how I know!)

Not every planner lasts. Our lives change, and what we need from our planners change with them. If the planner you picked so carefully stops fitting your life, that’s not failure. That’s information.

The sooner we stop forcing it, the sooner we find what actually works. So, grab your favorite pen, colored pencil, highlighter, washi tape, or stickers, read each sentence below, and mark the ones that sound like you:

Take the quiz. Be honest. Your planner already knows.

☐ 1. You can’t remember the last time you opened it.

If the most recent entry is a dentist appointment from spring, that’s not a pause.

☐ 2. You’re planning everywhere but your planner.

Sticky notes on the fridge. A running list in your Notes app. The back of a receipt. If your real plans live somewhere else, your planner already knows it’s been replaced.

☐ 3. It’s too pretty to write in.

You’re saving the pages for “when life calms down.” Spoiler: it won’t. A planner you’re afraid to mess up is a planner you won’t use.

☐ 4. The layout fights you.

Busy days get a tiny box. Quiet weeks get big empty hourly columns staring back at you. If you’re constantly squeezing, crossing out, or skipping whole sections, the format isn’t built for how you actually live.

☐ 5. It doesn’t come with you.

Too heavy for your bag, too big for your desk, too precious to leave the house? The best planner is the one that’s there when the thought hits.

☐ 6. You feel guilty every time you see it.

Every blank week feels like a small judgment. Planning should feel like a deep breath, not a report card.

☐ 7. You’re already shopping for a new one.

You have tabs open. You’ve watched the flip-throughs. You know the paper weight of a planner you don’t even own yet. Friend, your heart has already moved on.

Your Results

0–2 CHECKS: Just a rough patch.

Every relationship has slow seasons. Try a reset: clip out the past months, add a fresh dashboard, and choose one section you’ll use every single day. Start small and see if the spark comes back.

3–5 CHECKS: Time for the talk.

Something isn’t working, but you may be able to fix it. Before you shop, figure out what’s wrong. Is it the size? The layout? Daily versus weekly? Write down what you love and what you skip. That list is your map to the right fit, whether that means new inserts or a new planner.

6–7 CHECKS: It’s time for a break. And that’s okay.

Let it go with gratitude. Move birthdays, goals, and anything important to your next system. Keep the pages that mattered. Then start fresh. You don’t have to wait for January.

Before You Commit to Your Next One

Ask yourself three questions:

1. When do I actually plan? (Morning coffee, the Sunday reset, on the go)

2. What do I need to see at a glance? (My day by the hour, my week, my month)

3. Where does it need to live? (My bag, my desk, my nightstand)

Answer those, and you’ll stop dating the wrong planners.

Breaking up with a planner doesn’t mean you’re bad at planning. It means you’re learning what works for you. And for people who live life on paper, that’s part of the journey.

Here are just a few of my favorites:

For the Flexibility Seeker
You need a planner you can take apart and rebuild as often as your life changes.

• Jane’s Agenda: My current planner, and the one I’d hand to any flexibility seeker. Discbound means pages move, swap, and disappear as needed, with no commitment to a layout that stopped working in March.

• Levenger Circa smartPlanner: A longtime discbound standard with a polished, professional feel, ideal if your planner goes to meetings with you.

For the Hour-by-Hour Crowd
You live by appointments, errands, and notes to self, and you need room for it all.

• Hobonichi Techo: A page for every day, smooth Tomoe River paper, and a whole year in one compact book.

• Passion Planner Daily: A full page each day, with built-in space for priorities and the bigger goals behind them.

For the On-the-Go Planner
Your planner lives in your tote all week, so it has to keep up without weighing you down.

• Hobonichi Weeks: Tall, slim, and pocket-friendly, with a week at a glance and space for notes beside it.

• Moleskine Weekly Notebook: Simple and sturdy, a week on the left and a lined page on the right. Lots of colors.

Finding Your Perfect Match

This is only the beginning. Our special edition, The Planner Issue, is on its way and packed with planner goodness.

I originally joined Substack because of BINDER, the magazine I’m building for people like me, who love planners, paper, creativity, and the whole world that surrounds them.

I was not looking for another social media platform. I was looking for my people.

Planner people. Writers. Creators. Small brands. People making beautiful things. People building something from an idea. People who still get ridiculously excited about paper.

Does Substack start to understand me based on the writers and publications I interact with? If I intentionally follow people whose work overlaps with the world I’m trying to build around BINDER Magazine, will I naturally begin finding more of that community? And maybe more interestingly, will they begin finding me?

Subscribe now

Leave a comment

For some people, planning is a quiet Sunday ritual. For others, it happens five minutes before the day starts. Or, like me lately, in between meetings and during lunch, at my desk.

So tell me: where do you plan?

And tell me what’s usually beside you when you plan: coffee, stickers, books, headphones, snacks, all of the above?

I’m collecting answers for BINDER, and I’d love to hear your planning plans and how you plan.

Leave a comment